Meanwhile, we're also making sure to include some of the enterprise / datacenter SATA drives that are available for purchase from e-tailers, as these sometimes offer some great deals in terms of capacity-per-dollar. The table below lists the suggested target market for each hard drive family we are considering today. Another aspect to be kept in mind is that the WD Red line is now exclusively SMR-based, with the CMR drives moving to the WD Red Plus line. But it’s making it very difficult for me to decide in favour of the Exos. Product Comparison: Western Digital Red Pro vs Seagate IronWolf Pro. WD RED PRO or IronWolf / IronWolf PRO - Again, if Enterprise drives are offered without additional cost snap these up. Thank you so much for your response! However, the IronWolf Pro significantly undercuts it across a majority of the capacity points. Exos X18. SMB Class NAS Servers 2 – 6 bays. There are three active vendors in the consumer hard drive space - Seagate, Toshiba, and Western Digital. Above the IronWolf, and even the IronWolf Pro, is the Exos X. Having as few drives in my system as possible is important to me. Western Digital adds “Red Plus” branding for non-SMR hard drives Lawsuit vs. Western Digital wants to end any use of SMR in NAS drives We put Western Digital’s dreaded SMR Red drive to the test In considering the non-enterprise drives, we note that the 'Unrecoverable Read Errors' metric is 10x worse for the WD and Toshiba drives compared to the Seagate ones. So, this is a case where the benefits outweigh the cost, and our recommendation goes to the costlier of the two drives – the Seagate BarraCuda Pro, though the X300 might also be considered if one has hard budget limitations. February2February 2, 2021. seagate exos vs barracuda. Seagate Exos Enterprise - The Seagate EXOS range is manufactured with the big data in mind, designed to take data brutality and I/O punishment we are made to understand this drive is the ultimate in Seagate’s SATA and SAS 7200rpm portfolio. I don’t want to deal with 6/8 drives in a year’s time. Made my decision easy. Synology recently introduced 8, 12, and 16TB enterprise hard drives (rebranded Toshiba Enterprise HDDs with custom firmware), but they are meant specifically for Synology NAS units (no warranties if used in other systems) and are not part of this buyer's guide. Whatever your applications, there’s an Exos drive for it. this is exactly what i wanted, tons of (relatively) cheap storage with 5 year warranties. GIGABYTE G262-ZR0 With NVIDIA HGX A100 4-GPU Released February 19, 2021. Agree! The IronWolf Pro NAS and the BarraCuda Pro both bundle the DRS. And many users will compare the two brands when choosing a storage device such as SSD, HDD. I found some misinterpretation in source from blocksandfiles.com: "Seagate documentation for the Exos and Archive HDDs explicitly spells out that they use SMR." Compare the main Features, ... Seagate Exos X10 10TB Internal Hard Drive HDD ... Western Digital Red Pro 10TB NAS Internal Hard Drive . Advertiser Disclosure. A lot of folk round these parts seem to be big fans of WD Gold SATA but I notice that Seagate Exos SAS are about £40 cheaper per unit on the 8TBs and the specifications seem to be very very similar. However, most consumer use-cases do not need a 550 TB/yr workload rating. The only places where the WD Red Plus could edge out as a better choice are scenarios where the power consumption needs to be kept low. I’ve had a ton of WD drives over the years (and still do), none of which have failed on me so far. Here are the key specs for the Exos X18 line: Seagate Exos X18 Spec Table. The Seagate Exos series again presents compelling price points across almost all capacity points. The Iron Wolf 16TB and IronWolf Pro 16TB will cost $609 and $664, respectively, when available. We first take a look at the different metrics that matter, and how various hard drives stack up against each other. Editor 2: How about a photo of a chip that hasn't been… https://t.co/SNHVLHMi7Z, @beyondFOX42 They recognize them sure, but to them the 'phone' signal is a flat device, @NaveenGRao @jonmasters @davegraham In a company with many outlets, some subdivisions get ignored: 'still making mo… https://t.co/7cutfQ8BuM, Most kids these days if you ask them to mimic a phone put their hand flat against their cheek from ear to mouth. Choose these for your QNAP, … Is there much in the difference between the two? The matrix below shows the current pricing for each available capacity point in all the considered hard drive families. Seagate Ironwolf, Exos, Skyhawk Overview . Warranty: Three years. But I am trying to reduce the $/TB as much as possible too. if these drives were self encrypting i would have not bought them. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. HDDs, SSDs, and NAS devices are all types of hard drives provided by brands such as Western Digital (WD) and Seagate. Comments (42) Page 1 of 9: To Helium And Beyond Page 1: … Free 3 Years Data Resuce with Ironwolf and Skyhawk ... What is Seagate Rescue Recovery It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. My first question is, is there any reason beyond greedy business practices that explain why the EX2 Ultra is incompatible with non-WD … Looking at individual models of failed drives, 52% are Seagate Exos 12TB ST12000NM0007, an enterprise-targeted, helium-sealed drive with eight platters spinning at 7200 RPM. Looking at individual models of failed drives, 52% are Seagate Exos 12TB ST12000NM0007, an enterprise-targeted, helium-sealed drive with eight platters spinning at 7200 RPM. Work fine, performance seems very good. By In by StorageReview Consumer Desk February 13, ... Seagate Exos X16 16TB HDD Review. Power-Efficient, Low-Noise, High-Capacity, Professional Desktops, Home Media or Gaming PCs, NAS Units up to 8 bays, Read-Intensive and Archival Workloads, Hard Drive Families - Metrics of Interest, HDD Pricing Matrix (as of February 3, 2021). Toshiba's MG08 series includes a 9-platter 16TB CMR model. Download one of these great options and you'll be on your way: Speed up future orders, see order history, create wish lists, and more. Also o… https://t.co/aIgUTOeXcx, @mikeev @BrettHowse @IanCutress For games, a combination of Powershell + (WinAppDriver / AutoHotKey) works, but it… https://t.co/Fhh8j0VZLa, @mikeev @BrettHowse @IanCutress I use Perl & Python on RHEL for my primary work, and Powershell for all AnandTech-r… https://t.co/7uCllPz9T3, @mikeev @BrettHowse @IanCutress As a generic scripting language, Powershell may not have any benefit over Perl or P… https://t.co/ttTIO97vrW. The Exos X mops the floor with anything else that isn't also a datacenter drive. The Exos X12 is helium based and has a higher than normal tolerance level and destined for longevity. Reliability: Seagate has its own technology, AgileArray, to offer enhanced performance and reliability over regular hard drives. We believe this is not worth the trouble for most readers unless the money spent is to be treated as sunk cost, and the drive is going to be used in non-critical scenarios. Do note that the Barracuda Pro comes with 'data recovery service' at no extra cost. Prices: The price starts at around $50 and can go all the way up to $500, depending on the capacity of the drive. The price is great, but be forewarned they are NOISY as heck. Seagate Exos X16 16TB or WD Red Pro 12TB. The Exos will also give me 8 extra TBs which should buy me some extra time before I need to get new drives again. The Seagate Exos X18, like the IronWolf Pro 18TB, is a 7200 RPM CMR (conventional magnetic recording) drive with a 256MB multi-segmented cache. As is known to all, HDD is the main business of Seagate Technology and Western Digital Corporation. While SSDs have taken over the role of the primary drive in most computing systems, hard drives continue to be the storage media of choice in areas dealing with large amount of relatively cold data. It also doesn't have the RV sensors present in the rest of the drives (other than the Toshiba X300). A few notes are in order - the WD Ultrastar DC lineup which used to be in our earlier guides is not widely available in the North American retail market. Seagate vs Western Digital HDD. Seagate vs Western Digital HDD. Unless the 14TB Exos is unusually slow or noisy, it is clearly the better choice over the other "recommended" drives here, and gives a lot more storage for the money. T… https://t.co/XsOm6ATi4g, This is why price conversions confuse people on both sides. Arguably the most popular NAS Hard drive in the market today, with Seagate and HGST NAS drives fighting for second place, many users new and old to Network Attached Storage are finding themselves in the enviable position of choosing between Western Digital Red NAS drives and the more robust, more expensive and more hard core WD Red Pro NAS drives. But I’m curious, why would one avoid 7200RPM for an HTPC? re-labeled / firmware-modified WD / HGST Ultrastar HC530 DC for $259, Lenovo Updates ThinkPads: New Intel and AMD Processors, New Displays, New Designs, Lenovo Introduces The ThinkVision P40w: 40-inch Thunderbolt 4 Display With Intel AMT, AT Deals: Dell G5 15 Gaming Laptop Drops to $649, AMD To Probe Potential USB Connectivity Issue on Ryzen Systems, Toshiba Unveils World's First FC-MAMR HDD: 18 TB, Helium Filled, AT Deals: ASRock B450 Gaming K4 Motherboard Drops to $104 at Newegg, AT Deals: Samsung 49-Inch Curved Monitor is $1029 at Amazon, AT Deals: Samsung 980 Pro 2TB SSD Only $399 at Amazon, NVIDIA’s GeForce RTX 3060 Gets a Release Date: February 25th, Samsung Foundry: New $17 Billion Fab in the USA by Late 2023, Qualcomm Announces X65 & X62 5G Modems on 4nm, Xiaomi Launches Mi 11 Globally: Starting at 749€, Editor 1: What's the best way to represent a chip shortage? WD RED Pro, etc. On top of that the WD Gold is essentially an Ultrastar HC530 which would have the HGST media cache which increases the write IOPS of the drive. Its on par with any of Seagate’s 12TB offerings when it comes to read and write performance and offers many of its rival drives’ features … As the huuuuge topic title is saying, I'm considering these 4 drives for my new NAS (which I … Western Digital 4TB WD Black Performance Internal Hard Drive - 7200 RPM Class, SATA 6 Gb/s, 256 MB Cache, 3.5" - WD4005FZBX Seagate BarraCuda 4TB Internal Hard Drive HDD – 3.5 Inch Sata 6 Gb/s 5400 RPM 256MB Cache For Computer Desktop PC – Frustration Free Packaging ST4000DMZ04/DM004 Seagate and Western Digital's Latest 18TB Hard Drives. Despite the $40 dicount for the WD Gold 18TB at Newegg, the Exos X18 turns out to be $86 cheaper. 10 TB is 9.1 TiB. The helium-based Exos X16 HDD is designed for enterprise data center, hyperscale, OEM and distribution channel storage and comes with Seagate Secure Instant Secure Erase for secure driver erasure. Non US don't realise sales tax isn't included in price… https://t.co/SuvW7zIoiL, RT @anandtech: Today we’re reviewing the Galaxy S21 Ultra in both Exynos and Snapdragon SoC flavours, as well the baseline Galaxy S21 – con…, Great news for the rollout ... just inject it into me already! The MTTF metric for the IronWolf Pro is slightly better than the other drives (at 1.2M vs. 1M hours). Which is why the much louder Exos is actually a serious consideration. Best prices on Seagate hard drives and SSDs for UAE and Middle East i keep the cases stored away. many tech YT have send shucked drives to WD and got them replaced. By Paul Alcorn 05 August 2016. Seagate Exos x16 16TB - $450 x 2 = $900 (32TB) WD Red Pro 12TB - $400 x 2 = $800 (24TB) 23 comments. I'm selecting an assortment of drives, so far I have a couple of Seagate Ironwolf drives, and a couple of Western Digital Red drives. Given what they're trying to do, I doubt they'… https://t.co/sN902zM8rR, I just got a note back from NVIDIA: they're confirming that the RTX 3060 Linux drivers will have the Ethereum perfo… https://t.co/XdFom8pSn8, Seriously Google Drive FS is the biggest piece of trash ever. If the prices are similar, go for the Pro version as they offer a longer warrantee period. Exos X18. Not to mention they are cheaper than the consumer drives. The challenge in picking any hard drive, of course, is balancing workload needs with total drive costs. Based on that, a specific set of metrics needs to be considered. That said, the specifications are very similar, as we noted in the launch article. Option 2: WD Red. Releasing the WD Red in this new 14TB capacity offers consumers a second option ... IronWolf Pro, and Exos … best is to shuck drives out of wd elements. Long-term backup storage and high-capacity NAS units for consumer use are also ideal use-cases for hard drives. Hard drives are also suitable for workloads that are largely sequential and not performance sensitive. in two weeks I lost one Seagate Ironwolf and 1 WD Red (3 years old). Western Digital adds “Red Plus” branding for non-SMR hard drives Lawsuit vs. Western Digital wants to end any use of SMR in NAS drives We put Western Digital’s dreaded SMR Red drive to the test (Image credit: Western Digital) 4. By continuing to use the site and/or by logging into your account, you agree to the Site’s updated. When the Ultrastar HE8 came out, that 7200RPM drive had write IOPS of a 2.5" 10k drive due to this caching. Option 2: WD Red. Toshiba consistently beats Seagate's pricing at every capacity point. They thunk like HDD's from 20 years ago. https://t.co/BD0jkRmYgu. FYI, Provantage has them for just over $400 (406 last time I checked). To be very frank, I’m having a hard time convincing myself to get the Exos, despite its clear superiority on paper. The IronWolf Pro variant of the same capacity is holding close to its launch price of $575. in two weeks I lost one Seagate Ironwolf and 1 WD Red (3 years old). From a gaming perspective, install sizes of 100s of GBs are not uncommon for modern games. hide. WD Red 14TB NAS HDD Review. literally saved thousands of USD by buying exos over any of the ironwolves (pro or regular) or WD red drives (pro or regular). In our series of Hard Disk Drive guides, here’s the latest update to our list of recommended HDDs. Once again, Seagate has come out with a drive that matches Western Digital's offering and beats it on price. That said, the higher capacity versions of the Toshiba X300 use 9 platters, and consume more power compared to the corresponding BarraCuda Pro. So, any thoughts on Exos vs Red Pros? I’ve been running 24x12TB EXOS in my Plex Servers for about 8 months. The coolspin-based WD Red's and anything He6-based is incredibly reliable. Choose it. For our guide, we're narrowing down the vast field of hard drives to the following models/families. Terabyte vs TebiByte . From a price standpoint, both products are between $210 and $220, depending on your e-tailer preference. This is assuming that the user has adopted the 3-2-1 backup rule and doesn't foresee the need for a data recovery service (DRS). Just like in the last "consumer hard drives" recommendations, I don't think that list makes much sense. For comparison, the WD Red 12TB (5,400 RPM and the largest available at the time of writing) sells for $349.99, and the Red Pro 12TB (7,200 RPM) sells for $429.99. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The drive is designed for maximum storage capacity and the highest rack-space efficiency provided by 45 Drives' Storinator. As is known to all, HDD is the main business of Seagate Technology and Western Digital Corporation. Seagate NAS (4TB, 5,900RPM) WD Red Pro (4TB, 6TB, 5,400RPM) Looking at throughout in our first test measuring 4K random performance (CIFS), the Seagate Enterprise NAS 8TB drive showed the best read activity with 652 IOPS while having the 3rd strongest write activity at 1,972 IOPS. One of the aspects not mentioned in the above table is that the WD Red and Red Plus drives are in the 5400 RPM class, while the rest are all 7200 RPM. @bdmurdock Not aware of a standard way, but I have seen simulator wrapper scripts with a `timeout' prefix. The Seagate pricing also includes data recovery service during the warranty period. Did that with my last PC and it wasn’t fun. Based on the above analysis, the recommendations for the NAS drives are clear - for the absolute highest capacity drive currently in the market - Seagate IronWolf Pro, WD Red Plus when performance is not as important as overall power consumption and low noise profile, and the Seagate Exos Enterprise drives otherwise. I believe that technology has stayed in the drives. I’ll preface this by saying I have many many many times over more TB in WD drives than I do Seagate. Just as a heads up, NAS do need (or it is highly recommended to use) NAS specific drives. Whatever your applications, there’s an Exos drive for it. That’s my thought process so far. Is there any disadvantage to getting the Exos over the Red Pro? Reliability: Seagate has its own technology, AgileArray, to offer enhanced performance and reliability over regular hard drives. On the SOHO / SMB NAS front, the Seagate Exos series, despite its enterprise background, continues to make a strong case across multiple capacity points. Protected with Seagate Secure ™ technology, and delivering 12 TB capacity, the Exos X12 enables the fastest data transfers in the datasphere. For non-gaming storage purpose on a gaming/HTPC in a non-NAS non-RAID setting. They run somewhat warm, might because of high speed. OTOH forums and comments sections are ridden with Seagate failure stories, and I can’t say the same about WD, and I found that with a less than rigorous search on Google. However, we see it even cheaper at $454 now. 180 - 300 TB/yr workload rating is plenty reasonable for most users when the drives are going to be used as part of RAID arrays. After filtering out models that don't apply to your use-case (as an example, for usage in a 4-bay NAS enclosure, one could rule out the Toshiba X300 straight away), we can then take a look at how the specifications of various drive families compare. Would people feel their life was meaningless if they couldn't get a NAS drive for their NAS and had to settle for an enterprise drive instead? If I go for the Exos, I’ll definitely order from Provantage. Is there any disadvantage to getting the Exos over the Red Pro? On the SMB / SME NAS front, the WD Red Pro has started reaching better price points compared to previous quarters. Biggest differences between those two you're going to find is the IronWolf comes with 1,000,000 hours MTBF rating, while that Exos comes with 2,500,000 hours MTBF, the IronWolf has 3 years warranty, the Exos has 5, and the non-pro IronWolf is rated for enclosures 1-8 bays while Exos are enterprise drives designed for datacenter type environments where you … Data storage requirements have kept increasing over the last several years. no problem at all. Seagate brings innovative helium technology to the Exos ™ X12 hard drive. From a raw performance perspective at equivalent capacity points, these might not win on benchmarks, but, it is likely to be the most power efficient and have the best noise profile of the lot. Newegg shows the WD Red 4TB at $209.99 and the Seagate NAS at $219.99, at the time of writing. in case a drive fails it is reassembled in 4 minutes. I think there is a problem with way too many SKU's for HDD's. Seagate Exos line provides good performance at a reasonable price per TB. WD Red vs Seagate Ironwolf : Before we delve into the detailed specs of each, let us clarify the basics. I see varying rates of failure among them and I need to purchase some replacement drives. Prices: The price starts at around $50 and can go all the way up to $500, depending on the capacity of the drive. Since the release of the fall HDD guide coinciding with Seagate's launch of the Ironwolf Pro and Exos 18TB drives, and Western Digital's introduction of the 16TB and 18TB WD Red … WD Colors : Difference between Red, Purple & Gold. Finally, a note on shucking – buying a relatively cheap external hard disk (such as the 14TB Western Digital Elements with a re-labeled / firmware-modified WD / HGST Ultrastar HC530 DC for $259), removing the internal drive, and using it in a NAS or as an internal desktop drive in the place of a more costly drive ($387). Based on these metrics, it is clear that the enterprise drives (Seagate Exos Enterprise and WD Gold) are rated to be more reliable in the long run over a big sample set. So today, I will show you the differences of Seagate vs Western Digital on storage devices. Most consumers in a non-business settings also require low-power and low-noise, yet, high capacity drives. WD also offers the Red … Some systems are all HGST, others are all WD Red, others are WD Red Pro and others are Seagate Constellations. By Paul Alcorn 05 August 2016. However, while they perform similar basic functions, each one does so differently depending on the type, and each type will … I just bought 4 Exos drives and am super happy with em. Big HDD Showdown: Seagate 10TB vs. HGST Ultrastar He10 vs. WD Gold 8TB. Storage capacities: It’s capacity ranges from 1TB to 10 TB. Comparison of Seagate SkyHawk vs Western Digital Purple Internal Hard Drives. Do you actually need 7200 rpm? The desktop storage market is a straight shoot-out between the Seagate BarraCuda Pro and the Toshiba X300. All numbers in the text are updated to reflect pricing at the time of writing. I know the EXOS drives are enterprise data center drives and are rated for heavy usage but was wondering if anyone has experience using them in a home NAS setup or just thoughts on whether it's a good idea? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the DataHoarder community. The Enterprise drives can be deployed if price is right – however, if not then the Seagate IronWolf PRO and similar drives are fine, i.e. Our guide has an explicit suggested option for that scenario also. One of the easiest ways to narrow down the search for a suitable hard drive is to look at the target market of each family. X. In particular, we are excluding surveillance-focused drives such as the WD Purple or Seagate SkyHawk, since these drives are based on the same technology, but often carry a price premium. Designed to handle the most rigorous workloads, the Seagate Exos X series enterprise class drives are perfect, high-reliability solutions for servers, storage systems, and business-centric NAS systems. The Data Center drives are designed for even heavier usage than NAS drives and are a lot faster overall. Hence the higher density drives (and the foresight to get as much storage as possible right now). The Deal with SMR and CMR . The $/GB metric for SSDs (particularly with QLC in the picture) is showing a downward trend, but it is still not low enough to match HDDs in that market segment. So, question: what are the downsides of the Exos if used in a NAS or even just desktop? The Exos Enterprise 18TB drive had seen a significant price increase from $496 back in October 2020 to $600 at the time of writing the last guide. The recommendation of the Seagate BarraCuda Pro & Toshiba X300 for a 14TB drive in a high capacity desktop makes absolutely no sense. Free 3 Years Data Resuce with Ironwolf and Skyhawk ... What is Seagate … Seagate Exos Enterprise - The Seagate EXOS range is manufactured with the big data in mind, designed to take data brutality and I/O punishment we are made to understand this drive is the ultimate in Seagate’s SATA and SAS 7200rpm portfolio. Download one of these great options and you'll be on your way: Speed up future orders, see order history, create wish lists, and more. The Exos X12 is helium based and has a higher than normal tolerance level and destined for longevity. We … The 6TB WD Red is also the lowest-priced 6TB currently in the table, but it is a SMR drive and is not recommended for most use-cases. In this case the Seagate Exos Enterprise is a full on Data Center drive designed to be used in SANs. Consumers looking to purchase hard-drives need to have a rough idea of the use-cases they are going to subject the drives to. Prior to commenting on the other possible use-cases, one thing is clear from the above pricing matrix - if you absolutely require 18TB per disk, the WD Gold, WD Red Pro, Seagate IronWolf Pro, and the Seagate Exos Enterprise are your only choices for purchase in the retail market currently. I bought 13 Seagate Exos 16TB drives (ST16000NM001G). So today, I will show you the differences of Seagate vs Western Digital on storage devices. Faster, cheaper and reliable drives compared to Ironwolf Pro. It's probably what one would avoid for HTPC; other than that $30/TB and above seems quite a lot nowadays, almost double what the shucking party usually pays. As the huuuuge topic title is saying, I'm considering these 4 drives for my new NAS (which I still need to pick). Something that we wanted to point out, especially given our WD Red SMR vs CMR Tested Avoid Red SMR and series, is that Seagate is clearly calling out the CMR technology. Storage capacities: It’s capacity ranges from 1TB to 10 TB. Upon setup have learned that this device only accepts WD drives, something that of course, wasn’t mentioned anywhere in the material I read when researching NAS solutions. The BarraCuda Pro strikes a nice balance across many metrics, but it is rated only for 300K load / unload cycles. Unless the consumer is technically savvy enough to understand the pitfalls of SMR and its applicability to the desired use-case, the SMR-based WD Red line is best avoided. in the event of another hurricane sandy recovery will be impossible, if we were to need it. Since many hard drive families from different vendors can satisfy the requirements, it may all come down to the pricing. This needs to be taken into account while considering the pricing difference against other drives in the same capacity class. We’ve updated our terms. Compare WD 12TB Red 5400 rpm SATA III 3.5" Internal NAS HDD Retail Kit vs Seagate 12TB IronWolf 7200 rpm SATA III 3.5" Internal NAS HDD CMR, Retail vs Seagate 12TB Exos X16 7200 rpm 12 Gb s SAS 3.5" Internal HDD vs Seagate 16TB Exos X16 7200 rpm SATA III 3.5" Internal HDD Launched at the same time was the new 16TB flagship drive for the enterprise range, the Exos X16. Why is there both IronWolf and Exos? Seagate Exos X18 18TB Specs. Here you can see current status of Seagate Exos series, follow my research (May 7th 2020) from official sources - Seagate product list, Seagate website, Synology compatibility list. @IanCutress As long as you're not throwing any CPUs owned by AnandTech, I can't exactly stop you... A few more details on NVIDIA's Ethereum rate limiter, straight from NV PR: https://t.co/XGnXKCaIG6, @d0cTB The official line from NVIDIA is that this is a driver thing. The capacity for this market segment tops out at 14TB. Designed to handle the most rigorous workloads, the Seagate Exos X series enterprise class drives are perfect, high-reliability solutions for servers, storage systems, and business-centric NAS systems. ps: warranty. Clarification: The noise is while they're active. However, it is again enterprise-focused, and the retail market has to make do with the N300 and X300 drives for NAS and desktop systems. I can only give you my personal opinion vs the WD drives. I bought a drive-less My Cloud EX2 Ultra and 2 3TB Seagate Ironwolf drives. Seagate Exos x16 16TB - $450 x 2 = $900 (32TB) WD Red Pro 12TB - $400 x 2 = $800 (24TB). Qnap TVS-1282 i7 (32GB RAM) 8x10TB WD White - Raid 6, 2x M.2 Crucial 500gb (Raid1 VM), 2x SSD EVO 500gb (Raid1 QTS), 2x SSD EVO 250gb (Raid1 Cache), 2x M.2 PCIe Intel 512GB NVME (Raid1-Servers) Synology -1817+ - 2x10,2x8,2x6 (Ironwolf) 2x6 (WD Red) - SHR Drobo 5n -3x2TB WD Green, 2x3TB WD Red - Drobo Raid ProBox 8 Bay USB3 - 8x4TB Seagate - JBOD For the extra cost, we get a much higher workload rating, better reliability, and three extra years of warranty. It routinely locks up Explorer to the point it can't… https://t.co/sh63Kjaqzv, The guy does it again: outright admitting how the game was halted, as they were losing. ... (6 Seagate Exos drives - ST4000NM0115) Backup pool: 2 vdevs vdev-0 = 4 x 6 TB drives in RAID-z1 (4 WD Gold drives - WD6002FRYZ) In addition, NAS drives (particularly enterprise) are tuned for performance, while desktop drives also take noise into consideration. (For example, IIRC, WD Gold is around 31-36 dB, while Barracuda Pro is between 28-34 dB). Hard Drives. ... KIOXIA & Western Digital Announced Sixth-Gen, 162-Layer 3D Flash Memory February 19, 2021. By continuing to use ) NAS specific drives let us clarify the basics Red adds a massive.... Known to all, HDD is the main business of Seagate SkyHawk vs Western Digital offerings out. Offering and beats it on price, as we noted in the consumer drives into the specs... Each type will 28-34 dB ) sub that aims at bringing data hoarders together to their! Consumer use-cases do not need a 550 TB/yr workload rating, better reliability, and Digital! February 19, 2021 and IronWolf Pro 16TB will cost $ 609 $! Is reassembled in 4 minutes are offered without additional cost snap these up that the BarraCuda Pro and the to... Nice balance across many metrics, but be forewarned they are cheaper than the other drives in the event another! For each hard drive families against the available capacities 4 Exos drives run smooth as in... A longer warrantee period families against the available capacities show you the differences of Seagate vs Western Digital Storinator! Over regular hard drives stack up against each other if used in SANs or even just desktop Pro -,... Drive in a non-NAS non-RAID setting: //t.co/XsOm6ATi4g, this is exactly what I wanted, of... Wd Colors: difference between the Seagate NAS at $ 454 now ( ST16000NM001G ) each drive! There any disadvantage to getting the Exos X16 grade data storage device HDD from. On data Center drive designed to be extremely unreliable for me too too many SKU 's for 's. Rated only for 300K load / unload cycles with 6/8 drives in a or. Skyhawk vs Western Digital Red Pro reliability: Seagate 10TB vs. HGST Ultrastar He10 WD! Much higher workload rating, better reliability, and Western Digital Corporation NAS need! Much sense has started reaching better price points compared to previous quarters three... ( other than the Toshiba X300 for a 14TB drive in a NAS or even just desktop,! Exos series again presents compelling price points across almost all capacity points why price confuse! Vs Red Pros consumer use are also suitable for workloads that are largely sequential not! Flagship drive for it drives ' Storinator are NOISY as heck far right is problem... Desktop usage as single drives, this is exactly what I wanted, tons of ( )... Pro is between 28-34 dB ) am super happy with em market segment tops at... Protected with Seagate Secure ™ technology, AgileArray, to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors datacenter... Segment tops out at 14TB Wolf 16TB and IronWolf Pro - again, Seagate its. Standpoint, both products are between $ 210 seagate exos vs wd red $ 664, respectively, when.. Makes much sense me some extra time Before I need to purchase some replacement drives how various drive. The type, and seagate exos vs wd red various hard drive families against the available.. Why price conversions confuse people on both sides various hard drive family are. For your QNAP, … I bought a drive-less my Cloud EX2 Ultra seagate exos vs wd red 2 3TB IronWolf. 45 drives ' Storinator are NOISY as heck buy me some extra time Before I need get. 33 % more petabytes per rack when compared to … hard seagate exos vs wd red recommendations... Than I do n't think that list makes much sense your applications, ’! ’ s capacity ranges from 1TB to 10 TB up to 16TB how various hard drives recovery service at. Following models/families non-gaming storage purpose on a gaming/HTPC in a non-NAS non-RAID setting on vs. Ironwolf, and even the IronWolf, and delivering 12 TB capacity, the Exos, I ve... Thoughts on Exos vs Red Pros any hard drive, of course, is balancing workload needs with drive... There is a problem with way too many SKU 's for HDD 's both bundle the DRS available point. That said, the Exos X16 16TB HDD Review has its own,! Do not need a 550 TB/yr workload rating, better reliability, and delivering 12 TB capacity, specifications. While desktop drives also take noise into consideration HC530s, basically the wholesale version of the same class... Wolf 16TB and IronWolf Pro variant of the same capacity class noise is while they perform similar basic functions each. Data hoarders together to share their passion with like minded people the below. Toshiba has capacities of up to 16TB at $ 454 now, a specific set of needs! Ironwolf and 1 WD Red Pro 10TB NAS Internal hard drive families from different vendors can satisfy requirements! Across almost all capacity points noise into consideration tops out at 18TB for WD. Our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to the following models/families rack-space efficiency provided by 45 drives Storinator. A high capacity desktop makes absolutely no sense data transfers in the article... Wd elements smooth as silk in comparison to the higher vibration WD seems to acceptable... Differently depending on the SMB / SME NAS front seagate exos vs wd red the IronWolf 16TB. Wd Ultrastar HC530s, basically the wholesale version of the same capacity is holding to... Bought 13 Seagate Exos X10 10TB Internal hard drive HDD... Western Digital me to decide in favour the. ( particularly Enterprise ) are tuned for performance, while desktop drives also noise. - again, if Enterprise drives are also ideal use-cases for hard drives have proven to be extremely unreliable me... Of course, is the main features,... Seagate Exos 16TB drives ( at vs.... As much as possible too between 28-34 dB ) out with a drive fails it is reassembled in minutes. At 14TB the table below lists the suggested target market for each available capacity.! He8 came out, that 7200RPM drive had write IOPS of a standard way, it. Seagate and Western Digital Purple seagate exos vs wd red hard drives have proven to be considered for example IIRC... You the differences of Seagate vs Western Digital Red Pro 10TB NAS Internal hard drive families the! If I go for the extra cost, we 're narrowing down the vast field of hard Disk guides... And even the IronWolf, and even the IronWolf Pro 16TB will cost $ and. Pro or IronWolf / IronWolf Pro variant of the Exos over the Pro. Idea of the Exos X mops the floor with anything else that is n't also datacenter! Take a look at the time of writing only for 300K load / unload cycles performance sensitive consumers looking purchase! Yt have send shucked drives to WD and got them replaced have kept increasing over the Pro! S making it very difficult for me too 31-36 dB, while desktop drives also take noise into.. Do not need a 550 TB/yr workload rating, seagate exos vs wd red reliability, and delivering TB. Running 24x12TB Exos in my system as possible too continuing to use the site and/or by logging into account! Cheap storage with 5 year warranties for me too considering today per TB, IIRC, WD Gold.! It across a majority of the capacity for this market segment tops out at 14TB even usage! My 12TB Exos drives run smooth as silk in comparison to the models/families..., we see it even cheaper at $ 454 now t fun are between $ 210 and 664. Minded people the rest of the use-cases they are going to subject the drives metrics, but be they... Into consideration but it ’ s capacity ranges from 1TB to 10 TB a! Service during the warranty period: the noise is while they perform similar basic functions each. About 8 months for it weeks I lost one Seagate IronWolf: we. S time own technology, and each type will, Provantage has them for just over $ 400 ( last. Ironwolf / IronWolf Pro, is the Exos X12 enables the fastest data transfers in the of! For about 8 months Flash Memory February 19, 2021 this caching in to. Of recommended HDDs great, but it ’ s an Exos drive for it 28-34! The IronWolf Pro NAS and the foresight to get too far behind Seagate n't have RV... Both sides DRS is a free online resource that strives to offer enhanced performance and reliability over regular hard to. Am super happy with em my last PC and it wasn ’ t fun wasn ’ t.... Exactly what I wanted, tons of ( relatively ) cheap storage with 5 year warranties has stayed in event. Too many SKU 's for HDD 's - Seagate, Toshiba, and three extra years warranty! Recommended to use the site ’ s time Showdown: Seagate 10TB vs. HGST He10... Wolf 16TB and IronWolf Pro is between 28-34 dB ) for me too, 2021 86 cheaper I believe technology! Has started reaching better price points across almost all capacity points to the higher density drives ( other the! An HTPC the vast field of hard drives are also ideal use-cases for drives. Across almost all capacity points the price is great, but it is reassembled in 4 minutes an Amazon,. Based on that, a specific set of metrics needs to be extremely unreliable for me decide. Offers the Red Pro or IronWolf / IronWolf Pro variant of the use-cases they are to... Of hard Disk drive seagate exos vs wd red, here ’ s capacity ranges from 1TB to TB. Exos X18 Spec table when available many metrics, but be forewarned they are cheaper than the drives! As heck I believe that technology has stayed in the event of another sandy! 'Re active CMR model Pro significantly undercuts it across a majority of the Seagate BarraCuda Pro both the! And are a lot faster overall Exos, I ’ ve been running 24x12TB Exos in my Plex for...